Phish — A Live One
(Elektra 61777-2, 1994/1995, 2CD)
by Rob Walker, Published 1995-11-01
Ask any Phish fan and they'll tell you that the band's natural habitat is most definitely on stage, in front of a live audience. So after five studio albums, Phish finally present a sonically impeccable, meticulously chosen collection of their live material on this double CD set. Those who are intrigued by the studio CDs, but have yet to attend a Phish concert or get hold of any of the widely distributed tapes of the band's shows can now finally get a real feel for the live Phish experience. Or can they?
A Live One, compiled mostly from Phish's fall '94 tour, is notable for including versions of several unreleased and somewhat "rare" tunes, as well as for presenting a taste of the bands unique improvisational excursions. But what this release also does is ignore songs that represent significant elements of Phish's bouillabaisse of musical styles, and fail to make clear that each of these tracks was taken from a different show; this is not representative of a single Phish concert. With that minor gripe aside, one can generally applaud the selection of each of these specific performances. Some, such as "Stash" and "Harry Hood," are among the finest versions the band has ever created live. The big question mark though is the 30-minute "Tweezer." Chosen to show off Phish's more exploratory side, this version undoubtedly has some very significant meaning to the band as performers, but unfortunately much of that is lost on the listener who was not a part of that magical moment of creation. The problem is not in the length, but in the cohesiveness of the musical nooks and crannies which are explored in this almost completely improvised piece. Indeed, this version is one of the more disjointed improvisations of the entire fall tour; a better choice might have been the brilliantly flowing and well developed 45-minute "Tweezer" from a month later, which had two rather nondescript minutes snipped out of it and plopped on the CD as "Montana." An even better choice would have been a completely different song, such as "David Bowie," which arguably gave rise to the most interesting improvisational explorations of 1994.
In the end A Live One is a solid, but by no means exceptional release. For those who've been craving a well-produced live album from Phish, this should go a long ways towards satisfying their desire. It is interesting to note, however, that during the month of June when this album came out, Phish put on a series of concerts which in many ways put the performances included here to shame. If they someday release a live set culled from their 1995 shows, watch out!
Related artist(s): Phish
Wolfgang Dauner RIP – Pianist Wolfgang Dauner, one of the pioneers of both European free jazz and jazz rock, has died at the age of 84. With his own groups and with the United Jazz+Rock Ensemble, his playing and compositions were a prominent presence in European jazz from the mid-60s until just recently. » Read more
Michael Allison RIP – Michael Allison, who since 1997 has been recording as Darshan Ambient, passed away on January 9th after a long and brave battle with cancer. He has been at at the forefront of the new ambient/electronic music scene, with over eighteen releases to his credit. » Read more
Neil Peart RIP – One of rock music's defining drummers has died at the age of 67. Neil Peart's work with Rush provided one of the templates for percussion in rock, and he certainly ranks in the top ten most influential drummers of the 20th Century. Peart retired from playing in 2015 due to health issues, and succumbed to brain cancer on January 7, 2020. » Read more
Joel Vandroogenbroeck RIP – Word has reached us of the death of Joel Vandroogenbroeck, best known as one of the founders of Brainticket, He also recorded electronic music under a variety of names. He was born August 25th, 1938 in Brussels, Belgium and died December 23, 2019 in Arlesheim, Switzerland, aged 81. » Read more